Org.Works Horizontal Logo

The Strategic Discipline You’re Not Managing

In nearly every major strategic model— McKinsey & Company 7S, Weisbord’s Six-Box Model, Burke-Litwin, the Star Model, and Leavitt’s Diamond—structure is treated as a foundational element. And for good reason. The way a company is organized affects everything including accountability, operational effectiveness, speed, innovation and culture.

Yet in today’s corporate landscape, organizational design has become a lost discipline. It’s too often treated as an afterthought, a reactive exercise leveraged only for cost cutting, or worse—a performative box-check before announcing the next reorg.

The Structure Is the Foundation, Not the Shifting Sands

When companies treat organization structure like a variable instead of a foundation, they invite instability. Teams can’t focus. Decision rights blur. Priorities drift. Repeated restructuring sends a message: nothing is settled. If your structure keeps shifting in response to trends or personalities, your company isn’t evolving—it’s eroding.

Organization design must be adaptive, but it can’t be arbitrary. When structure becomes fluid while strategy demands stability, execution falls apart.

You Can’t Design Around People or the Latest Trend

Designing around star performers, specific personnel situations, legacy leaders, or whatever is disproportionately trending this year (CX, AI, ESG, Metaverse) may buy temporary gratification, but it won’t build long-term clarity or capability. When companies reorganize to accommodate personalities or hot topics, they often hardwire confusion into the system. It becomes unclear who owns what, who decides, and how success is measured.

Structure should serve strategy, not individuals or trends.

Reorgs for Cost Cutting Aren’t the Same as Org Design

Let’s be honest: many reorgs are budget exercises disguised as strategy. Roles are collapsed, layers removed, and headcount reduced—but rarely is the underlying structure redesigned with intention. That’s not design. That’s just downsizing.

Cutting cost without designing for capability leads to brittle organizations. And once markets rebound, those same companies find themselves scrambling to rebuild what they dismantled.

Reclaiming the Discipline

Far too many companies redesign their organizations with little more than gut feel and PowerPoint. There’s rarely a consistent logic applied—no guiding criteria (less indiscriminate spans and layers mandates), no cross-departmental modeling, no stress testing of decision rights. Structural design should be just as rigorous as financial modeling, product roadmapping, or customer segmentation.

If we want performance, speed, operational effectiveness, and cultural clarity, we must restore organizational design to its rightful place: as a deliberate, strategic discipline. That means:

  • Treating structure as a first-order decision, not a downstream consequence.
  • Using structure to create clarity, not accommodate complexity.
  • Applying real design logic and not letting politics, personalities, or panic dictate org charts.
  • Evaluating effectiveness regularly, not just when forced to by budget constraints or leadership changes.

Key Questions to Bring Rigor to Your Org Design:

  • What are we optimizing for?
  • How do we measure whether this design is working?
  • Will this design solve current clarity and ownership gaps?
  • How are processes changing as a result of this organizational change?
  • How does this design benchmark against competition or best-in-class teams?
  • Will this design stand the test of time even if the players change?
  • Can this structure scale as we grow or adapt to shifts in strategy or changing market conditions?

If we don’t reclaim the art and science of org design, we’ll keep wondering why our strategies don’t stick, our transformations stall, and our employees are burned out and confused.

The answer isn’t hidden. It’s the structure. It always has been.

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/strategic-discipline-youre-managing-dr-janet-sherlock-uz7fe/?trackingId=Z4o86wW4RJGMPDQw83KaIQ%3D%3D

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Janet’s advisory services, based on her extensive knowledge of ecommerce, technology, and organizations were game-changing for us. We built our digital organization around Janet’s recommendations with great results.
    COO
    Major Footwear Company
    The research and recommendations from Janet’s research should be required education in every boardroom.
    President
    Major Technology Company
    Dr. Sherlock’s recommendations on Product Management saved us from building an unnecessarily complex organization.
    CEO & CIO
    Global Data & Risk Services Provider
    Passion. Smarts. Expertise. Unprecedented leadership and organizational skills. Janet Sherlock stands out in a crowded field of consultants!
    HR Executive
    Global Apparel Company
    We relied upon Dr. Sherlock’s invaluable expertise to help us determine the reporting structures, remit, and approach for AI across our agency.
    Chief Transformation Officer
    Federal Government Agency

    Sign up for our newsletter

    Get organizational tips, advice and more delivered directly to your inbox.
    Organization Design Advice, Focused on Clarity & Results